• Me

  • Welcome! My name is Kelly, and I am a picky eater. On this blog I share recipes, new (to me) foods, restaurants, and products that I try in an effort to expand my tastes. You might also find me talking about my pug Olive, Miss Kitty, Project Life, my journey with running, and more! Feel free to contact me: [email protected]

  • LINKwithlove

Macaroni and (Long Island) Cheese (Squash)

I’m back from Las Vegas!

When I come home from a trip, I always look forward to making my own meals.  Don’t get me wrong, I love good restaurant food as well, but after four days of trying to figure out what to eat – its good to be home.  (Speaking of good restaurant food, one night of the trip we went to a pretty fancy restaurant and had a chef’s tasting menu!  It was so good, I can’t wait to share it with you.)

So, as my first meal back home, I decided to make something new.  Heather posted this recipe recently, and so I decided to try it.  I have never had squash before, but  I love macaroni and cheese, so I decided to give it a go.  You can find her recipe here.

I’m pretty sure Long Island Cheese Squash doesn’t exist in Wisconsin, so Heather suggested I use Butternut Squash instead.  Confession:  I had to google what a butternut squash looks like.  Truth.

Here is another reason why I love the Grocery store I go to:

Local Butternut

They have signs telling you which products are local, and how far away they come from.  Pretty cool, and an easy way to shop local!

So, with squash (and a latte) in hand, I went home to start dinner.

Once I got home, I proceeded to make the noodles and cut up the squash.

Butternut Squash

I did use shells instead of macaroni noodles since I had some on hand.  For my cheeses I used about 3/4 cup cheddar, 3/4 cup mozzarella and 3/4 cup ricotta.  Oh, and in case you couldn’t guess, I left out the cayenne pepper – as I’m sure you are all well aware, I don’t do well with spicy.

Then, after preparing it all, I realized that I didn’t have any aluminum foil to cover the pan.  Fail.  So, instead of running out to the store to get some foil, Heather recommended I just use a cookie sheet and place it at a slight diagonal to give it some airflow.  So thats what I did.

Pan Cover

It worked, and my dinner came out perfectly!



Seriously, it was so good.  The cinnamon and the squash added substance to the baked mac and cheese.  And, of course, the breadcrumbs on the top were a huge part of the goodness as well.

Ease: B, there is some chopping and prep work, but nothing too horrible or difficult.
Taste: A+, seriously, so good.  I’m glad my first experience with squash was a good one.

Would I make it again? Yes.  In fact, I’m thinking about making it to bring to Thanksgiving dinner – the squash makes it Thanksgivingy, and the noodles make it something  I love. 🙂

I just realized that this is the fourth variation of Macaroni and Cheese that I’ve made (so far)!

The first was the Baked Mac and Cheese Cupcakes

Mac and Cheese Cupcake

Then the Macaroni Lasagna

Macaroni Lasagna

Next was Macaroni, Peas and Cheese

Macaroni Cheese and Peas

And then today’s delicious Macaroni and (Long Island) Cheese (Squash)

What is your favorite way to eat Macaroni and Cheese?

7 Responses

  1. So happy ýou loved it 🙂

  2. I love cheddar mac with *a little* goat cheese and *a lot* of broccoli added…

    this looks fabulous too!

    I cannot wait to hear which restaurant you went to! 😀

  3. I looooooovvvvve mac n cheese too!! I def want to try this one, it looks and sounds delicious! I am also interested in hearing about the chef’s tasting menu! 🙂

  4. […] on Pinterest.  The recipe seemed easy enough, so I decided to go for it.  Everyone loved the Squash Mac And Cheese that I brought to a previous gathering, so I thought they might like this as well.  You can find […]

  5. […] tasting, and it was kind of gritty (I’m assuming from the butternut squash?)  I am a fan of other butternut squash mac and cheese, but not a fan of this version. 2) Kashi Soft and Chewy Berry Muffin bars.  I suppose in an […]

  6. […] chili ever.  Chili seems to go great with cold air and football watching on the weekends. 2) Butternut Squash Macaroni and Cheese from Then Heather Said.  I love this fall dish, and I need to be making it more.  (It makes for great leftovers, […]

  7. […] a bit, I have gotten a bit more adventurous than just the blue box.  Sometimes I add veggies (like this butternut squash mac) and in general, I am a bigger fan of the baked version than the stovetop version. (like this […]

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: